I keep seeing RAG (Retrieval-Augmented Generation) pop up in job descriptions and on engineering resumes. I tried looking it up, but I was still struggling to understand what it actually was.
I had one engineering manager break down the architecture for me. In a nutshell, RAG allows an AI model to retrieve information from relevant documents or data sources before generating a response. Instead of relying solely on what the model learned during training, it searches for relevant information and uses that context to formulate an answer.
But be careful, if the system retrieves the wrong information, the model can still produce a perfectly written, reasonable-sounding answer that’s…completely wrong.
I wanted to dig deeper, so I took a couple of questions to my engineering manager, Ryan.
Q&A: Understanding RAG Through a Quality Engineering Lens
1. How do you actually test a RAG pipeline?
I went to Ryan and basically asked: How do you verify that the system is retrieving the correct information, using relevant context, and generating an accurate response? What are some of the testing scenarios or failure points a QE should be looking for?
Here’s what he said:
First, test retrieval.
We need to validate that the system finds the correct documents or data sources. For example, if we ask a question about a company’s vacation policy, does it retrieve the current HR policy or an outdated version? We can create a controlled set of questions with known relevant documents and measure how consistently the system finds them. We should test ambiguous queries, misspellings, synonyms, and questions requiring information from multiple documents.
Second, test context relevance.
Retrieving the correct document doesn’t necessarily mean the AI receives the right information. Documents are often split into smaller chunks, and important context can be lost. We want to confirm that the retrieved passages contain the information needed to answer the question, without introducing unrelated or conflicting information.
Third, test response generation.
This is where we validate that the AI’s answer is accurate, relevant, and supported by the retrieved information. For example, if the HR policy states that employees receive 15 vacation days, and the AI responds with 20, that is a failure even if the response sounds reasonable.
We also need to verify that the model doesn’t invent information when the answer isn’t available. Sometimes the correct behavior is to say it doesn’t have enough information.
What Should Recruiters Be Asking?
So, what does all of this mean when we’re interviewing candidates who have worked with RAG applications?
Here are a few questions I’d add to my recruiter toolkit:
1. What tools and technologies have you used to build or test RAG applications?
Listen for specifics around LLMs, embedding models, vector databases, retrieval frameworks, and evaluation tools. More importantly, ask what they personally worked with versus what was already in place.
2. How have you tested whether a RAG application is retrieving the right information?
Have they used a set of questions with known answers or relevant source documents? How did they measure whether the system was finding the right information?
3. How do you test for incorrect, outdated, or conflicting information?
For example, what happens when a system retrieves an outdated policy instead of the current one? How would they identify and catch that?
4. How do you validate that an AI-generated response is actually supported by the information it retrieved?
This gets into whether they’re checking for factual accuracy, relevance, and hallucinations rather than simply checking whether the application returned a response.
5. What do you test when the answer isn’t available in the source material?
Does the system know when it doesn’t have enough information, or does it generate an answer anyway? How would they test that behavior?
My point: Don’t just ask candidates whether they’ve worked with RAG or which tools they’ve used. Find out what they were responsible for testing, what failure scenarios they considered, and how they knew the system was producing reliable results. A candidate saying they’ve tested a RAG application doesn’t tell you much until you understand their specific role and what they actually validated.
2. How is testing a RAG-based application different from traditional software testing?
So what makes it more challenging? Are traditional assertions and expected-result testing sufficient, or do engineers need to introduce new evaluation methods to assess things like response relevance, factual accuracy, and hallucinations?
Here’s what I learned:
The biggest difference is that traditional software testing typically validates deterministic behavior, while RAG applications introduce probabilistic behavior, which is not necessarily deterministic.
In traditional automation, we might provide a specific input and assert that the output equals an expected value. With RAG, asking the same question multiple times can yield different responses. Those responses might all be correct, or they might differ in factual accuracy, relevance, or completeness. That makes traditional exact match assertions insufficient for evaluating the entire application. However, traditional testing techniques are still extremely valuable. We still need functional testing, API testing, integration testing, performance testing, security testing, and regression testing. The difference is that we need to supplement those methods with AI-specific evaluation techniques.
What else is important for recruiters to understand about this concept??
